Like many popular CW series, Hart of Dixie was one that touched quite a few hearts (no pun intended.) After it was canceled, many fans were wondering if the show would get a follow-up season 5 on Netflix, similar to what happened with another CW legend, Gilmore Girls. If you’re one of those many Hart of Dixie followers that’s hoping for some direct information about one of your favorite shows, we can help you out with some relevant info.
And if you’re looking for more, similar shows to Hart of Dixie, we’ve got you covered there, too. It’s no surprise that a show with such a relatable, enjoyable cast of characters would gain so many followers, so read on if you’d like to know more about the series’ potential future!
If you’ve been watching drama on the CW for quite a few years, then you’re no stranger to the ebb and flow of the network’s different series. Some of them stick around for many years, while others receive neat closure that’s satisfying to shows’ fans. Occasionally, you’ll run into a particular series that doesn’t meet viewer and feedback requirements, which results in a show’s untimely and unfortunate cancellation.
The latter is what eventually happened to Hart of Dixie. After struggling with ratings for more than a year, it was abruptly announced in 2015 that the fourth season of the beloved drama/comedy would be its last.
A poor end to an otherwise interesting show, but after that cancellation, fans weren’t ready to give up on it.
Hart of Dixie
For the uninitiated, Hart of Dixie was a blend of comedy and drama that centered around the journey of a single protagonist — Doctor Zoe Hart. After failing to achieve her dream of becoming a New York heart surgeon, she ends up moving to a fictional Gulf Coast town to continue working as a general practitioner.
The first season follows a few predictable steps — an urbanite experiences and learns the charms of small-town living — but the most refreshing thing about Hart of Dixie is its cast of characters. They’re genuinely funny, but never at the expense of being entirely relatable. Rachel Bilson was a hit as Zoe Hart, and the rest of the supporting cast had great performances, too. Jaimie King’s turn as Lemon Breeland — a sour character, with just as ironic of a name as Hart — also gets some fantastic storylines that provide for strong conflict and interesting narrative developments.
Why Was the Show Cancelled
As is the case when many shows are canceled, Hart of Dixie met its end due to ratings. The CW is a great place for shows to thrive, since so many tune into the network counting on excellent viewing experiences. However, the presence of so many good shows on a single network means that competition is fierce, and inevitably, some shows decline in viewers and fall through the cracks.
That said, Hart of Dixie did manage to persist through four strong seasons, during which the show and its characters earned a huge number of fans. It was nominated for a handful of awards during its time, too, which only complements the high regard that so many people hold for it.
In most circumstances, cancellation of any type is a show’s death knell, unless it gets picked up by another network. And the longer that a series has been around, the more difficult it’s going to be to recover gracefully and become profitable, wherever it ends up. Hart of Dixie’s four seasons cemented its place in fandom but doesn’t necessarily do much to ensure that we’ll see more of the show.
While speculation has remained strong in the years following this show’s cancellation, there’s no news of it being renewed on the CW. This long after it was canceled, there’s even less reason to await its return.
However, with so many fans’s still feverishly excited by their hope for a fifth season, many have been turning their attention to other avenues by which Hart of Dixie could be renewed. There isn’t exactly a lack of precedent for such hope, either; several other shows that were unceremoniously canceled due to declining ratings did get an eventual future in other media. Just recently, CW legend Gilmore Girls was picked up by Netflix, where it continued as a four-episode miniseries.
It’s not the only show that’s been given new life through other means. Sci-fi fans will remember Firefly, which originally aired on Fox. After a botched delivery of out-of-sequence episodes that led to viewer confusion and disappointment, the show was canceled. In retrospect, this was a hilariously poor move, as Firefly proceeded to develop one of the most fervent, loyal fan followings that a TV show could ask for. What did that result in? A feature-length movie with a sizeable budget that eventually made its way into theaters.
The “Netflix Hope”
The growing trend of Netflix picking up fan-favorite shows doesn’t seem to be slowing down. Moreover, it seems that these renewed “surprises” tend to generate quite a lot of hype and revenue for the streaming giant, which only gives them more incentive to continue doing so.
Even though the Gilmore Girls revival didn’t receive quite as high of review marks as the original series, it was still incredibly well-received. Millions of people streamed it, and because of the Netflix show format, they’re continuing to do so. The same goes for Arrested Development, another canceled series that found new life on Netflix.
You don’t have to look far beyond Hart of Dixie to see that many other shows that faced cancellation are being heard in the same breath as “Netflix.” Intentional or not, the brand has become synonymous with the ability to give new life to shows that otherwise wouldn’t see the light of day again.
Will Hart of Dixie Continue on Netflix?
Unfortunately, there’s no way to know, for sure, if we’ll ever see Hart of Dixie. Quite a few things have to align in order for such a thing to happen. The show’s creators and cast need to be in agreement that more of the series is what they want to do. More importantly, a network or streaming provider with the means to finance and distribute such a production need to decide that it’d be a profitable, wise choice.
And for those of us who are eagerly speculating, it’s a bummer that none of those things is quantifiable or transparent. Essentially, we won’t know if they’re going to happen until they happen.
Is this a reason to give up hope? Absolutely not! The show’s most ardent supporters — and the loudest — are the best chance of getting anything to happen, on that front. Both the show’s creators and business entities like Netflix need to hear the support that people are throwing behind the idea. It worked for Firefly, Arrested Development, and Gilmore Girls. There’s no reason that enough support thrown behind Hart of Dixie wouldn’t increase its chances, as well.
Shows Like Hart of Dixie
For now, all that we’ve got is speculation, hope, and the perseverance of quite a few die-hard fans. Unless, of course, you look to the fact that there are quite a few other shows to watch. Hart of Dixie might have been a good show, but it wasn’t the only one telling interesting stories about relatable characters who are out of their environment. Heck, you can find plenty of great selection on the CW, alone.
Look no further than Gilmore Girls, which we mentioned earlier in the article. It features an endearing cast of characters, primarily in Rory and Lorelai Gilmore. It’s another CW gem that managed to drum up a massive number of fans and followers, such that it’s been one of those shows that Netflix picked up for a “renewal.”
And if you liked the youthful energy that’s so embodied by Zoe Hart, give Gossip Girl a shot. The settings and characters are wholly different, but the series features many similar themes and story beats. It’s all about drama, friendships, and the complexities of modern social circles. And if you dip further into the past, you can find shows like Everwood, which was introduced on the WB. It was primarily about the trials faced by a struggling family, but much in the same way as Hart of Dixie, the conflicts present at the show’s opening evolve and change as the characters’ lives unfold.
Though we certainly wish we could offer some promising news about that hypothetical fifth season of Hart of Dixie, all that we have is speculation, for now. Given the show’s four-season longevity and its cancellation due to low ratings, the odds are certainly stacked against it getting picked up for a continuation or renewal. Quite a few fans are still rooting for that very thing to happen, thanks to the precedent established by companies like Netflix. Only time will tell, though, so if you’re an ardent fan of the show, keep being loud about it! Meanwhile, let us know if you have any questions about Hart of Dixie or any of the other shows that we’ve recommended throughout the article!